Ask The Rabbi - #50
January 7, 1995 
===========================================================================      
This edition contains:
1.  Two Worlds -- Which is Better?
2.  Answers to Last Week's Riddle (4 names in Amidah).
===========================================================================      
Susan from Seattle wrote:

>Why is it that we mourn when someone dies, aren't they going to a better 
>place?  Shouldn't we be happy for them?

* * * * * * * * * *

Dear Susan,

Your question highlights the paradox of how we experience the death of a 
loved one:  Should we "be happy for them" as you say, or should we grieve 
deeply?

First of all, it is correct to mourn when someone dies.  The Shulchan Aruch 
states "It is a great mitzvah to eulogize the dead in the proper way.  The 
mitzvah is to raise one's voice and say those things that will break 
people's hearts to induce crying and to recall the praise of the one who 
has passed on."

The Talmud cautions, however, that this crying should not go on endlessly:
"There are 3 days for crying, 7 for eulogizing, and 30 days without 
laundering and haircuts.  Eventually, though, it must stop.  `Don't be more 
merciful than G-d.'"  This implies that there is a need to mourn, but with 
limitation -- that there is a reason to cry, but not forever.

On the other hand, it is also true that the deceased go on to a better 
place.  We are taught that "This world is [but] a passageway to the next 
world" -- the World to Come.

There are many reasons why we grieve when someone has passed away.  One 
reason is that we cry for our own loss.  We feel a genuine pain when losing 
someone close.  People cry because they feel lost without the loved one, or 
out of empathy for the pain that the orphans and widow(er) suffer.

Another reason for our grief is that the we are sad for the deceased's lost 
opportunities for accomplishment in this world.  There is an advantage to 
this world over the next.  In this world we show that we are worthy of 
receiving reward in the "next" world.  This is a reason for us to desire to 
live in a world of hardship and lies rather than to rush off to the World -
- to -- Come.  The Vilna Gaon is noted for saying "Look at what can be 
accomplished in this world!  For a few pennies you can buy a pair of 
tzitzit and fulfill a mitzvah.  In the World -- to -- Come, no amount of 
money can buy you a mitzvah."  For this reason people tuck in their tzitzit 
when entering a cemetery in order not to be inconsiderate of the feelings 
of the deceased (lo'eg l'rash).

Rabbi Yehuda Halevi points out that the Torah does not encourage us to 
belittle this life, and long for life after death.  Quite the opposite!  
The Torah makes it clear that we can enjoy the splendor of a deep and 
mystical connection with G -- d while here on earth.  Through prophecy and 
the like we enter the spiritual realm while still part of this world.  
While we are in this world, we are this-world centered, and are finally 
taken to the next world against our will.

Several years ago I asked Rabbi Michel Twerski of Milwaukee why we allow 
the Yamim Tovim (Festivals) to bring an early end to the shiva mourning 
period.  The law is that if a major Festival occurs during the shiva, that 
ends the shiva.  He answered that there are three advantages to the mourner 
from the shiva:  He relieves his anger at Hashem for causing this loss, he 
deals with denial of the event of his loved one's death, and he relieves 
the guilt he feels at being alive while the other is not.  The Yamim Tovim 
directly deal with the anger and the guilt.  When you properly celebrate 
the Yom Tov you see the "big picture" and the Divine providence in 
everything that happens.  After that, how can you be angry or feel guilt?  
"Denial" is important, but without the other two factors of "anger" and 
"guilt" it is not enough of a reason to allow us to continue the shiva and 
once again withdraw from the dynamics of everyday life.  Our lives were 
given to us to be lived to the fullest.

Sources:
o Shulchan Aruch  -- Yoreh Deah 344:1.
o Pirkei Avos -- 4:21.
o Talmud -- Moed Katan, 27b.
o Rabbi Yehuda Halevi -- The Kuzari, 1:109.

===========================================================================      

Last Week we posed the following riddle (submitted by one of our readers):

"There are four names listed consecutively in the morning Shmoneh Esrei 
with only one vav (instead of 3) separating them.  What are they?"

The answer we expected was [in Sim Shalom]:  "Sim Shalom Tova u'Vracha 
[Bracha] -- I know someone named Sim (and it's not Sy Syms).

However, the person who sent us the riddle actually meant that "all of the 
names are separated with a vav," and intended an answer that is also in Sim 
Shalom but further on:  Bracha v'Rachamim v'Chaim v'Shalom."

Haim Roman of Jerusalem College of Technology E-mailed us an unexpected and 
brilliant answer:  "In the Bircat Avot  [first bracha of the Shmoneh Esrei] 
-- HaE-l HaGadol HaGibor v'HaNora" which are four of the [descriptive] 
Names of Hashem.

Look for a new riddle next week!
===========================================================================  
This publication is available via FAX and REGULAR POST within Israel.     
For information, please send E-Mail to ohr@jer1.co.il   
or send a fax to 972-2-812890 with your name & fax number,  
or write to the address below.   
=========================================================================== 
Dedication opportunities are available for Ask the Rabbi. 
Please contact us for details. 
=========================================================================== 
   Jewish   L         EEEEEEEE  Prepared by Ohr Somayach Institutions   
     J      L         E         22 Shimon Hatzadik Street, POB 18103 
     J      L         Exchange  Jerusalem 91180, Israel 
J    J      L         E         Tel: 02-810315 Fax: 02-812890 
 JJJJ       Learning  EEEEEEEE  Internet: ohr@jer1.co.il 
=========================================================================== 
Written and Compiled by Rabbi Yehoshua Karsh, Rabbi Benzion Bamberger,  
  and various other Rabbis at Ohr Somayach Institutions, Tanenbaum College, 
  Jerusalem, Israel. 
Production Editor: Rabbi Moshe Newman         
Production Design: Lev Seltzer         
===========================================================================       
(C) 1995 Ohr Somayach International - All rights reserved.        
This publication may be distributed to another person intact without prior        
permission.  We also encourage you to include this material in other        
publications, such as synagogue newsletters.  However, we ask that you        
contact us beforehand for permission, and then send us a sample of an     
issue.

